Workshop basics

How to approach
a mechanical fault.

Most faults are found by working in a sensible order, not by guessing. This is the order that keeps a diagnosis honest and cheap.

A machine rarely fails without a reason, but the reason is often several steps away from the symptom. A noisy bearing can be a worn bearing, a misaligned shaft, a blocked oilway or the wrong belt tension. The job is to reduce those possibilities deliberately instead of replacing parts until the noise stops. The order below works equally well on a gearbox, a pump, a motorcycle, a washing machine or a radio-controlled car.

Start with what changed

Before touching anything, establish what is different from the last time the machine ran correctly. A new noise, a different temperature, a longer start, a smell that was not there before, a service that was just carried out, a part that was just replaced, a change of load or of operator: any of these narrows the search immediately. If nothing changed, ask when the symptom first appeared and whether it has become steadily worse or appeared all at once. A sudden fault tends to point at something that broke, loosened or was disturbed; a gradual one tends to point at wear, contamination or adjustment drifting out of tolerance.

Gather the machine's own evidence

Run the machine and use your senses before you use tools. Listen with the covers on and off, at low speed and at working speed. Feel for vibration and heat in the right places, with the correct precautions. Note where oil, coolant or grease collects, and whether the leak is fresh or old. Look at the wear pattern rather than the wear itself: a mark that repeats every rotation points to a rotating component, a mark that appears once per cycle points to something driven. Written notes made while the machine is running are worth more than a memory of it an hour later.

Work from the outside in

Check the cheap and accessible things first: supply, pressure, level, filter condition, belt tension, fasteners, connectors, cable damage, blockage and adjustment. These are the causes that account for a large share of real failures and cost almost nothing to rule out. Only when the straightforward checks have been eliminated is dismantling justified, and by then the notes should say what you expect to find inside. A careful external inspection also tells you what you will need before the machine is in pieces: seals, gaskets, clips and the correct tools.

Change one thing at a time

Replacing three components at once may fix the machine, but it teaches nothing and hides the cause, which will return. Make one change, test in the same conditions as before, and record the result. If a test is inconclusive, put the machine back to the state it was in before the test rather than leaving the change in place. Where a fault is intermittent, plan tests that can be repeated: a fault that appears only when warm, under load or after a cold start can be provoked deliberately once you know the conditions.

Record as you go

Photograph the assembly before dismantling, label groups of parts, and note orientation and fastener position. Record measurements as numbers, not impressions, and separate what was observed from what is assumed. When the fault is found, write down the cause in one sentence: the next person to see the same symptom, including your future self, will find it faster.

Know when to stop

Stop when a repair needs equipment, training or a safe working environment you do not have. This guidance is a way of thinking about faults, not a substitute for the manufacturer's procedure or for the rules that apply where the machine is installed.

More from the Workshop

About the Field Reference